Start with the rooms you use at the same time. If you cool a living room in the afternoon and one closed bedroom at night, room-by-room control is worth considering. If most rooms are occupied together and the home already has sound ducts, central air deserves a look.
Where mini splits fit
A ductless indoor unit serves the space its air can reach. A unit in a hallway may do little for a bedroom behind a closed door. Walk through the rooms with the installer and mark where a head, drain and refrigerant lines could go. Ask how a multi-zone option compares with separate outdoor units.
Where central air fits
Central AC sends air through ducts to multiple rooms. Have existing ducts checked for leaks, sizing and return airflow before assuming they can be reused as they are. In a home without ducts, include the space and construction needed to add them.
Make the quotes comparable
Give both bidders the same list of rooms and hours of use. Ask each to show what is included for electrical work, drains, equipment placement and access for maintenance. The best fit is the system that can serve the rooms you actually live in.